Skip Navigation

This Critical Debate is a part of the EDCollection:

Oh no, you’re missing out on great content!

This content contains copyrighted material that requires a free NewseumED account.

Registration is simple — and comes with full access to videos, artifact, interactives, shareable content, and more.

Sign Up
?

NewseumED is provided as a free educational resource and contains copyrighted material. Registration is required for full access. Signing up is simple and free.

or log in to your account

Once you create a free account, 
you’ll have access to:

  • Downloads
  • Videos and Artifacts
  • Interactives
  • and more!

This Critical Debate is part of a Debate Comparison:

See all Debate Comparisons
Duration
30-60 minutes
Topic(s)
  • Constitution
  • Protests
  • Religious Liberty
  • Supreme Court
  • World War II
Grade(s)
  • 7-12
  • College/University

THE CASE

You are the principal of a school in Charleston, W.Va. Your school district requires all students each morning to recite the Pledge of Allegiance while standing and extending an open arm to the United States flag. The district feels this practice encourages patriotism and good citizenship.

Two of your students — sisters — have objected to this policy. As Jehovah’s Witnesses, these students say it is against their religion to honor objects, idols or earthly governments. Their father has instructed them not to perform the salute or pledge.

When they first refused to participate, you sent them home for their behavior. But now they are refusing to participate day after day. Because they don’t want to be marked truant or tardy, they arrive in time for the pledge but remain seated during it. Each time, you’ve sent them home.

Their behavior is becoming a distraction, and now the girls’ family is threatening to sue the school district for violating their freedom of religion and speech, which are protected by the First Amendment.

Should you push the school district to change its policy and allow students to sit out this ritual?  

  1. Photograph of Gathie and Marie Barnett
    ?

    Gathie and Marie Barnett were at the center of a legal battle over whether public schools could force students to salute and pledge allegiance to the flag.

    Courtesy Gathie and Marie Barnett

    1. Yes. Schools can keep the salute and pledge, but participation should not be mandatory.

    The school district should not force individuals to do things that go against their religious beliefs. Schools should compromise to protect individual beliefs and expression.

  2. Photograph of Judge Advocate Ralph B. Gregg
    ?

    Ralph B. Gregg represented the American Legion, a military veterans' association that believed participation in the Pledge of Allegiance in public schools should be mandatory.

    Bettmann/Getty Images

    2. No. Allowing some students to not participate in the salute and pledge will do harm to your school community.

    The pledge is not a religious practice; it is a demonstration of good citizenship and a show of national unity. Student’s individual rights must be flexible to work with school policies that are made for the greater good.  

  • Should protecting First Amendment freedom of speech and religion be more important than protecting school rules or practices?
  • Do you agree with the family’s claims that such a requirement violates their freedom of religion? What about their freedom of speech?
  • As a principal, do you think saluting the flag and pledging allegiance are important in teaching civics and/or history? Does it help establish school unity?
  • Is there a difference between distractive behavior and disruptive behavior? Does it matter in this case?
  • Can you think of ways that might respect the family’s wishes and still maintain decorum in the classroom? What about making the students stand but not salute? Or having them wait outside the classroom door?


More from our EDCollections

Explore more content within this EDCollection, or browse through all of our Lesson Plans, Critical Debates, Themes, Exhibits, Digital Artifacts, Historical Events, Videos, and Interactives using our EDTool search.
Quick View

Related EDClasses & Training

  • First Amendment and Tinker

    Students learn about the groundbreaking 1969 Supreme Court case that protected student speech in public schools.

  • You Can’t Say That in School?!

    Students debate court cases to learn how far First Amendment protections extend in public schools, and why limits may be necessary.

  • Introduction to the First Amendment

    Students get a brief overview of the First Amendment rights and limits, and discuss what life would be like without them.

Keep in the loop.

Sign up for NewseumED updates and newsletter today.